(Answered) ENGL147N Week 6 Discussion 1: Rebuttals and Refutations

Initial Post Instructions

Part 1: Research & Review
Review this week’s lesson and reading. Find an academic source to back up your opposition’s point of view. This is a new source, in addition to the source you located last week.

Part 2: Application
Anticipating readers’ objections is one way to determine what other sections to include and support in your paper. Practice writing a counterargument that applies the Toulmin model. Incorporate one of the new sources you have gathered to present your opposition’s point. Strive for at least 5 developed sentences. Cite your source in APA format.

  1. Grounds / 1st Counterargument (your opposition’s point)
  2. Backing (establish credibility of the source)
  3. Warrant (evidence)
  4. Possible concession / conclusion

Answer the following prompts:

  • How were you able to remain objective while presenting the opponent’s point of view?
  • What challenges did you face obtaining evidence to back up the assertion?
  • Which conciliatory approach did you apply and why?
  • How was it effective?


Obesity Is a Disease

According to the author, “Obesity is a real epidemic and a public health problem, defined by The Obesity Society (TOS) as a disease, and not only an underpinning of major chronic diseases, but a serious debilitating condition in its own right.” (De Lorenzo, 2020) A disease is defined as an abnormal condition that affects the function of structure of an organism which is not caused by immediate external injury. There are guidelines and research that define and outline the pathophysiological and clinical implications of diseases such as obesity. Body mass index or BMI is used to clinically diagnose obesity. BMI is calculated by a ratio of weight in kilograms and height in meters squared. Classification of overweight is a BMI greater than 25 and obesity is a BMI over 30. More current research suggest that BMI is not the most accurate measurement of obesity as results may be limited in showing hidden fats. Obesity increases the risk and is linked to various other diseases such as heart disease….Please click the icon below to purchase the full answer at only $5.